Democrats Who Sent Message to Troops Respond to Trump’s Hanging Threat

The National Guard's takeover of Washington was illegal, a U.S. District Court judge ruled Thursday.

Judge Jia Cobb rules that the Pentagon “exceeded the limits of its authority” by sending troops to the nation's capital on “non-military crime-control missions” without the express permission of the city's leadership.
Donald Trump sent 800 National Guard members to Washington in late summer and federalized the Metropolitan Police Department to combat what he called a hellish landscape riddled with crime. By November the number of troops had increased to 2,000.
To justify the government's violation, the president pointed to rising crime rates, immigrant populations and homelessness, although the numbers he used were for 2023. The cherry-picked statistics misrepresented the state of crime in the nation's capital, which actually fell 35 percent last year, according to Metropolitan Police Department data touted by Trump's own FBI. This was part of a nationwide trend that saw violent crime has plummeted.

But while responsibility for foreign military activities rests with the president, Cobb determined that Trump lacks the necessary authority to federalize law enforcement in American cities, especially in Washington, where Congress reigns supreme.

“The Court rejects Defendants' far-fetched claims of constitutional authority, finding that such a broad interpretation of the President's Article II powers would negate Congress's role in governing the District and its National Guard,” Cobb wrote.

Cobb suspended her decision until Dec. 11 to give the Trump administration time to appeal.

The decision does not bode well for Trump's plans for the rest of the country, which involve using the National Guard to bolster his immigration agenda in Democratic cities. So far, Trump has deployed federal forces to Washington, Los Angeles, Chicago and Memphis—all cities where residents have publicly opposed ICE.

This story has been updated.

Leave a Comment