The en banc 9th Circuit Court of Appeals voted Tuesday night to overturn the panel's decision allowing the National Guard to deploy to Portland and will rehear the case.
9th district rejected rehearing a similar case in Los Angeles, prompting dissenting judges to write dire warnings about the military's intrusion into home life. The panel in the case, consisting of two Trump judges and a Biden judge, also overturned the district court's blocking of the Guard deployment.
Tuesday's vote will not affect the situation in Portland because the Guard has not been deployed despite the commission's decision earlier this month. The Trump administration incomprehensibly never filed an appeal one of the district court's temporary restraining orders prohibiting the deployment of guards from any state.
Read the 9th Circuit's order here:
“I urge my colleagues on this court to act quickly to overturn the majority’s decision before illegal troop deployments under false pretenses can occur,” she wrote. “First and foremost, I ask those watching this case unfold to keep faith in our judicial system just a little longer.”
9th district rejected rehearing a similar case in Los Angeles, prompting dissenting judges to write dire warnings about the military's intrusion into home life. The panel in the case, consisting of two Trump judges and a Biden judge, also overturned the district court's blocking of the Guard deployment.
Tuesday's vote will not affect the situation in Portland because the Guard has not been deployed despite the commission's decision earlier this month. The Trump administration incomprehensibly never filed an appeal one of the district court's temporary restraining orders prohibiting the deployment of guards from any state.
Read the 9th Circuit's order here:
“A majority of the sitting judges who were not recused” voted to vacate and hold rehearings, according to the brief order. The district judge requested the vote shortly after the panel, made up of two Trump appointees and one Clinton appointee, met last week. blocked lower court ruling protecting Portland from deployment. In a strong dissent from the decision, Judge Susan Graber, a Clinton appointee, asked her 9th Circuit colleagues to dispense with the majority opinion.
“I urge my colleagues on this court to act quickly to overturn the majority’s decision before illegal troop deployments under false pretenses can occur,” she wrote. “First and foremost, I ask those watching this case unfold to keep faith in our judicial system just a little longer.”
9th district rejected rehearing a similar case in Los Angeles, prompting dissenting judges to write dire warnings about the military's intrusion into home life. The panel in the case, consisting of two Trump judges and a Biden judge, also overturned the district court's blocking of the Guard deployment.
Tuesday's vote will not affect the situation in Portland because the Guard has not been deployed despite the commission's decision earlier this month. The Trump administration incomprehensibly never filed an appeal one of the district court's temporary restraining orders prohibiting the deployment of guards from any state.
Read the 9th Circuit's order here:
“A majority of the sitting judges who were not recused” voted to vacate and hold rehearings, according to the brief order. The district judge requested the vote shortly after the panel, made up of two Trump appointees and one Clinton appointee, met last week. blocked lower court ruling protecting Portland from deployment. In a strong dissent from the decision, Judge Susan Graber, a Clinton appointee, asked her 9th Circuit colleagues to dispense with the majority opinion.
“I urge my colleagues on this court to act quickly to overturn the majority’s decision before illegal troop deployments under false pretenses can occur,” she wrote. “First and foremost, I ask those watching this case unfold to keep faith in our judicial system just a little longer.”
9th district rejected rehearing a similar case in Los Angeles, prompting dissenting judges to write dire warnings about the military's intrusion into home life. The panel in the case, consisting of two Trump judges and a Biden judge, also overturned the district court's blocking of the Guard deployment.
Tuesday's vote will not affect the situation in Portland because the Guard has not been deployed despite the commission's decision earlier this month. The Trump administration incomprehensibly never filed an appeal one of the district court's temporary restraining orders prohibiting the deployment of guards from any state.
Read the 9th Circuit's order here:
